Spring naar inhoud

Our external social value creation

Our external social value creation

Gasunie believes that it must be possible to achieve the European and national emission reduction targets on time and that, as an energy infrastructure company, we can play an important role in this in our core area. By investing in the decarbonisation of society, we create external social value. We also create this value with our investments to facilitate the rapid closure of the Groningen gas field, by minimising the carbon and methane emissions relating to our natural gas transmission and by striving for a good ESG rating. In this section, we describe how Gasunie creates external social value.

Related material topics:
No. 1 Energy transition
No. 3 Safety of the network
No. 9 Relationship with stakeholders and local communities
No. 10 Customer-focused and transparent service and communication

Related SDGs:
11, 13, 15, 17

Relevant stakeholders:
Local residents
Customers
Shareholder
Ministries

Value created

  • Facilitating the closure of the Groningen gas field: pseudo G-gas production / Groningen gas field production (i.e. ratio): 5.1
  • Emission reduction through Gasunie Transition Pathway: -3.2%
  • Sustainalytics ESG rating from 24.4 to 19.3 and ISS ESG rating from C+ to B
  • Our own net Scope 1+2+3 emissions: 709kt
  • Safety of local communities: 0 uncontrolled events (target no more than 3)

Our contribution to the closure of the Groningen gas field

The NAM-operated Groningen gas field, which has for so long been the central source of the gas in Gasunie’s transmission network, will be switched to stand-by and eventually closed permanently. To enable the closure of the Groningen field our subsidiary GTS is carrying out a range of measures like building a nitrogen installation in Zuidbroek (in the province of Groningen) where imported high-calorific natural gas (H-gas) will be converted to Groningen quality (pseudo G-gas) and connecting bulk consumers of low-calorific natural gas (L-gas) to the H-gas network. GTS is also advising the Minister of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy on the timeline that can be followed to close the Groningen field without endangering security of supply.

More quality conversion

Gas production from the Groningen field was wound down further in 2021. In order to be able to keep supplying gas to the low calorific gas market, there was more conversion than in previous years. Over 2021, the amount of converted high-calorific gas increased by 2%, from 374 TWh (33.9 bcm) in 2020 to 382 TWh (33.9 bcm) in 2021. The associated volume of nitrogen used increased from 3.41 bcm to 3.55 bcm in 2021.

The relationship between pseudo G-gas production and production of Groningen gas
In the 2020-2021 gas year (October-October), NAM’s gas production from the Groningen field amounted to 7.8 bcm. That would have been five times as much if Gasunie subsidiary GTS had not been producing pseudo-Groningen gas (pseudo G-gas) by mixing nitrogen with natural gas imported from abroad. In total, we avoided the production of 39.3 bcm of Groningen gas during the 2020-2021 gas year.
 

Groningen and pseudo-G production over the last 7 gas years

  Groningen Pseudo-G
14/15 34.99 15.85
15/16 26.98 23.08
16/17 23.98 28.8
17/18 20.1 32.73
18/19 17.51 32.36
19/20 8.65 38.2
20/21 7.77 39.29

Advice to the Dutch Ministry

GTS issues advice to the State Secretary for Mining (formerly to the Minister of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy) about the level of production from the Groningen gas field that will be needed to ensure security of supply. This advice is issued annually, with additional advice issued if there is a substantial change in the supply and demand for low-calorific gas. GTS is legally obliged to inform the Minister of such changes.

In October 2021, we reported that the completion of the GTS nitrogen installation at Zuidbroek, where we turn high-calorific gas into low-calorific gas, would be delayed. Germany is doing its bit in accelerating the phase-out of production from the Groningen gas field by converting its complete L-gas market to H-gas. Even though Germany is on schedule with this conversion, and will need less L-gas this gas year than during the previous gas year, the actual reduction is less than expected. In early January 2022, we informed the minister on what this means in figures. We are currently conducting additional analyses in the form of an interim evaluation of the current gas year and by updating our models. In spring, we will issue the additional advice to limit the increase in Groningen production as much as possible during the current gas year.

On 31 January, GTS issued, as per its statutory duty, advice to the state secretary on the level of production from the Groningen gas field required for the next gas year. The main conclusion from our estimate for the 2022/2023 gas year is that the Groningen gas field will then only be a back-up.

Due to all the measures already implemented [see the figure below], production from the Groningen gas field has fallen sharply in recent years to a historically low level. We are absolutely positive that gas extraction from the Groningen field can be terminated soon. GTS remains committed to facilitating the reduction of the required Groningen production as quickly as possible while preserving security of supply.

INTERVIEW Greening the entire supply chain

For Gasunie, the energy transition does not end with the construction of infrastructure for new, sustainable forms of energy: our own business processes must become greener too. And this we cannot do without our suppliers. Peter Wagner, Head of On-Site Account Management Benelux at Linde, and Hans Jonk, Network Development & Planning Manager at GTS, explain how Linde and Gasunie’s sustainability ambitions are being realised in the production of green nitrogen.

Read the interview

Our investments in sustainable energy infrastructure

Working on the energy transition

In 2021, Gasunie will have spent more than 260,000 person-hours on the energy transition; this is equivalent to 9% of the total number of hours worked (permanent, temporary and interim). Converted into person-years this amounts to more than 150 FTEs.

Our investments in hydrogen

In June 2021, Gasunie was asked by the Dutch government to develop the hydrogen transmission network. This is a milestone in the Dutch energy transition and a milestone for Gasunie. A substantial financial commitment from the Dutch government followed in September, limiting the risk posed by having an insufficient number of customers in the start-up years and, with that, insufficient income during that time. In December, a letter from the government to parliament provided more clarity on the future organisation of the hydrogen sector. These three developments are pivotal in determining our activities in the field of hydrogen infrastructure in the coming decades.

Hydrogen backbone

Gasunie has its sights on developing a transmission network for hydrogen in the Netherlands that will connect the five Dutch regional industrial clusters, other industrial locations, storage facilities and import locations, and which will have connections with neighbouring countries. With the help of this regional and national infrastructure, the Netherlands will become the gateway to Europe for the global hydrogen market.

Gasunie subsidiary Hynetwork Services is the party responsible for developing the transmission network. The development of hydrogen transmission in the five regional clusters is one of the priorities. Hynetwork Services is now in talks with producers, consumers and port operators in these clusters. The pace and manner of developing the transmission network in the regional clusters, in the rest of the Netherlands and for the connections to other countries may differ.

The ultimate goal is to have a national hydrogen backbone, including connections to other countries, in operation by 2030. Our current expectation is that the backbone will be 1,183km long and will consist for 83% of repurposed pipelines from GTS’ current national natural gas grid.

HyWay 27

The Dutch government based its decision to have Gasunie develop the national hydrogen network on the HyWay 27 report, which described the findings of a study conducted by Gasunie, TenneT, PwC/Strategy& and the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy and the Ministry of Finance. The study confirms that zero-carbon hydrogen is needed to achieve Dutch climate targets, and concludes that a national hydrogen transmission network and storage facility is essential in each of the four infrastructure scenarios in the 2030-2050 Comprehensive Infrastructure Survey (II3050) in order for hydrogen to gain the desired key position in the energy supply. In the HyWay 27 study, the future national hydrogen transmission flows have been calculated on the basis of the II3050 scenarios. HyWay 27 also shows that a completion time of four years must be taken into account for each individual section of pipeline.
 

It takes four years to develop a hydrogen pipeline section

Government support makes the backbone possible

The development of the hydrogen backbone received a major boost in September 2021. In the budget proposals for 2022, the Dutch caretaker government announced that it would reserve € 1.3 billion for energy infrastructure projects that are important for the climate/energy transition. € 750 million has been reserved for the backbone over the next seven years. This money is intended to cover the ‘slow uptake risk’, that’s to say to bridge the years when the backbone is already in place, but sufficient supply and demand for hydrogen may not yet have arisen. In addition, the government is making € 35 million available for the development of large-scale hydrogen storage facilities.

Market consultation

With a view to developing the hydrogen backbone, Hynetwork Services conducted a consultation among market parties in industry and other sectors who want to make use of the hydrogen backbone. The consultation revealed that these parties want the transmitted hydrogen to have a purity of at least 98%. Their preference for entry and exit pressure is 50 bar for entry and 30 bar for exit. In October 2021, Hynetwork Services published a complete overview of the technical specifications that market parties would like to see.

Proposed policy on hydrogen market regulation

With the publication of the policy on hydrogen market regulation in December, the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy has provided clarity on Gasunie’s future role in the hydrogen supply chain. In addition to developing infrastructure, from the start of the development of the hydrogen supply chain Gasunie has also committed itself to a number of key, innovative initiatives for electrolysis. In our opinion, the fact that the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy has chosen to leave the upscaling of electrolysis to the market creates the desired clarity for everyone.

In concrete terms, this means that we will continue to participate in electrolyser-related feasibility studies, through which we can collect knowledge about how these installations will fit into our future hydrogen grid; however, we will not be a shareholder in either electrolysis installations or in consortia concentrating on the development of an integrated production network. 

Thinking ahead to international connections

Gasunie is of the view that the essential role of hydrogen in the future sustainable energy mix will only be fully realised once there is a genuine international network, so that supply and demand can effectively be matched – starting with the Netherlands and Germany. Therefore, in preparation for definitive transport connections between the two countries, an initiative must be taken in the short term to carry out tests and studies into the necessary technical and regulatory conditions for cross-border hydrogen transport.

Progress in hydrogen projects

Gasunie has organised hydrogen development activities along lines (‘pillars’) that focus on transmission, storage, conversion, offshore and import.

Transmission pillar
Rijnmond
In the Rijnmond region, Gasunie is realising a regional infrastructure under the project name HyTransPort. This new hydrogen pipeline will soon form the backbone of the hydrogen infrastructure in Rotterdam and will run from the Maasvlakte industrial area to the Pernis district. HyTransPort will connect the conversion park in the Maasvlakte area with the petrochemical, chemical and heavy industries and import terminals in the port area. A 200-megawatt electrolysis plant belonging to Shell will be our launching customer. We aim to make an investment decision in 2022, with the pipeline coming into operation in 2024 and connection to the national backbone following in 2026-2028.

Northern Netherlands
The north of the Netherlands is a suitable region for developing a green hydrogen economy. We are currently working on the permits for the northern section of the backbone and the agreements are being finalised with the first producers and customers. If everything goes according to plan, the northern hydrogen infrastructure from the first phase will become operational in 2025. Connections to Emmen in the Netherlands and the Ruhr in Germany (second phase) are up next, as well as a route leading towards Hamburg and Bremen, which would follow shortly after.

North Sea Canal area
In the North Sea Canal (Noordzeekanaal) area, Gasunie wants to realise a hydrogen pipeline between the port of Amsterdam and the IJmond region, where the canal meets the North Sea. This would allow users and producers of hydrogen to be connected locally. We are currently discussing the details of the future infrastructure with potential customers and stakeholders. Assuming a positive investment decision, the regional system could be operational in the second half of 2026.

Zeeland
Gasunie and North Sea Port signed an agreement in September for the development of a regional hydrogen transmission network in the industrial area between Vlissingen and the Terneuzen canal area. Industry in the province of Zeeland accounts for 33% of the current demand for hydrogen in the Netherlands, and so also for a significant part of the carbon emissions. With the arrival of a regional hydrogen network, the delta region of the province can accelerate the reduction of carbon emissions. The planned Hydrogen Delta Network NL should take shape in the coming years. In 2027, this regional infrastructure can then be connected to the national Dutch and Belgian hydrogen infrastructure.

GZI Next
GZI Next is an energy hub in Emmen, for which Gasunie, as a consortium partner, expects to take an investment decision in 2022. Gasunie’s contribution to the GZI Next project would be the construction of a hydrogen pipeline, which would mean looking into the repurposing of existing pipelines and possibly constructing and commissioning a new pipeline. Lastly, the possibility of additional biogas production will be investigated. In anticipation of the investment decision, in 2021 we already ordered the materials with the longest delivery time.

HyPerLink

Gasunie wants to build the HyPerLink in the north of Germany, where GUD’s natural gas network is located. This hydrogen backbone will stretch out over 610 kilometres and have a planned capacity of up to 7.2GW. HyPerLink can be constructed in phases between 2025 and 2030.

The large-scale expansion of wind farms off the German North Sea coast in combination with onshore and offshore electrolysis plants will allow the green energy generated at sea to be converted into hydrogen, which can then be transported via the HyPerLink hydrogen backbone to storage facilities and industrial and other end users.

Like the Dutch hydrogen backbone, HyPerLink can be constructed cost-effectively by converting existing natural gas infrastructure to transport hydrogen and, where necessary, by building new infrastructure. As things stand now, construction and commissioning should take place in phases from 2025 to approximately 2030.

Storage pillar
HyStock

In the energy system of the future, fossil fuels will no longer play a role, or only play a very limited role in balancing energy supply and demand. We believe that this role will have been taken over largely by hydrogen. However, the national hydrogen backbone cannot function with the required level of stability and cost-effectivelywithout a large-scale central storage facility.

Gasunie is working on determining whether four salt caverns can be developed in Zuidwending for the large-scale storage of hydrogen. This would allow large amounts of energy to be stored safely, efficiently and reliably. The first results of our investigations in 2021 were positive. If the demonstration tests in the first half of 2022 also show good results, Gasunie can continue with the development of the salt-cavern storage facilities, with the first salt cavern fully operational in 2026. The aim is to build storage capacity that meets the need for hydrogen storage in line with the agreements in the Dutch Climate Agreement. In October 2021, we set up a separate entity for our hydrogen storage activities, HyStock.

Hydrogen can be stored on a much larger scale and more cost effectively than electricity.

Conversion pillar
Djewels 1
At the Chemical Cluster Delfzijl, Gasunie and HyCC (the new hydrogen company of Nobian and the Green Investment Group) are developing a 20 megawatt electrolysis plant under the name Djewels 1. The knowledge gathered in the course of this project will make it possible to scale up to larger installations in the future. At this chemical cluster, there are both suppliers and consumers of hydrogen and green energy. An investment decision is expected in mid-2022. Gasunie and HyCC aim to have the plant operational by the end of 2024. As a result of the decision of the Dutch government that Gasunie may not become active in electrolysis activities, we will only remain a shareholder in Djewels 1 just until the project reaches the operational phase.

Offshore pillar
Winds out in the North Sea can be harnessed on a large scale to meet climate targets. The creation of a series of smaller ‘energy islands’ in the North Sea is a highly efficient way of doing just that. Gasunie is involved in three of these offshore hydrogen supply chain projects.

PosHydon
In the PosHydon research project, Gasunie and consortium partners are integrating offshore wind, offshore natural gas and offshore hydrogen on the Q13a platform of Neptune Energy. The process for making green hydrogen starts with converting seawater into demineralised water on the platform. This water is then converted into hydrogen using electrolysis, with wind power providing the electricity. The result is green hydrogen. With PosHydon, the project partners are gaining experience in the practical aspects of integrating energy systems at sea and producing hydrogen in an offshore environment, to see how offshore conditions, including salt, affect the electrolyser. The Netherlands Enterprise Agency (RVO) has awarded the pilot an Energy and Climate Innovation Demonstration (DEI+) grant of € 3.6 million. With this grant and a contribution from the consortium partners the pilot can get under way. Platform Q13a is located 13 kilometres off the coast of Scheveningen.

NortH2
NortH2 is a consortium in which Gasunie is working together with Equinor, Groningen Seaports, RWE and Shell Netherlands. The consortium is supported by the Province of Groningen. We are jointly investigating the feasibility of large-scale production, storage and transmission of green hydrogen. The aim is to be able to supply industry with around 4GW of green hydrogen over the next decade. But the ambition goes further than that. NortH2 wants to grow to approximately 10GW by around 2040 – meaning the production of approximately one megatonne of green hydrogen per year – cutting carbon emissions by 8 to 10 megatonnes a year. The electrolysis will initially take place in Eemshaven and later possibly also offshore.

We are currently working on a feasibility study. The first results are positive and provide assurance that work can be started on shaping a fully developed project in the foreseeable future. The consortium structure will change after the study phase. Gasunie will then stop as an investment partner, but will remain involved in the realisation of the required transmission infrastructure.

North Sea Wind Power Hub
The North Sea Wind Power Hub (NSWPH) consortium envisions building energy islands far out at sea, with connections to various countries. The islands would collect the electricity generated by surrounding offshore wind farms. Given the size and ambitions, the consortium partners expect that so much electricity will be produced that a large part will be converted into hydrogen. This is where Gasunie can be of great help, which is why we are an active partner in this consortium, which further includes network operators TenneT and Energinet.dk.

The initial capacity of the hub will be around 3GW, later to be extended to approximately 10GW. In February 2021, the Danish government took the decision to construct the first artificial island, which should be ready by 2030. The major challenge is bringing the anticipated huge amount of offshore wind energy generated to landing points onshore and integrating this into the energy system, especially given all the technical system adjustments and regulatory changes needed to enable this.

AquaVentus
The AquaVentus consortium intends to build 10GW in offshore wind farms near the North Sea island of Helgoland, combined with offshore conversion of electricity into hydrogen and transport of hydrogen to the German mainland through an infrastructure of pipelines. The AquaVentus programme has been subdivided into various projects, including the AquaDuctus project that involves the building of the required offshore pipeline network of approximately 400km that will be used to deliver the green hydrogen produced by the offshore electrolysis platforms to consumers on the mainland. Gasunie is an AquaDuctus consortium partner.

Element Eins/Clean Hydrogen Coastline
In November 2021, the parties behind the hydrogen projects Clean Hydrogen Coastline and Element Eins announced that they were merging these two initiatives. Clean Hydrogen Coastline (ArcelorMittal, EWE, FAUN, Gasunie, swb and TenneT) aims to develop a large-scale hydrogen supply chain in the north-western region of Lower Saxony. Element Eins (Gasunie Deutschland, TenneT and Thyssengas) envisions the development of a 100 megawatt electrolyser in Diele, Lower Saxony.

Together, these projects lay the foundation for an integrated hydrogen value chain that should be created by 2026, with hydrogen production, electricity infrastructure, large-scale hydrogen storage in salt caverns, and transmission via existing natural gas pipelines that have been repurposed as hydrogen pipelines. The collaboration agreement concluded in November forms the basis for further steps, including terminating the direct involvement of the participating network operators in the construction of the electrolyser, and obtaining financing. Clean Hydrogen Coastline has been granted IPCEI status*.

* An IPCEI (Important Project of Common European Interest) is a transnational project that, through public funding, makes a significant contribution to growth, jobs and competitiveness for industry and the economy in the EU.

Import pillar
Ammonia terminal
Studies such as II3050 and HyWay 27 foresee that north-western Europe will not be able to meet its own demand for green hydrogen in the future, despite large-scale production initiatives. This means that it will be necessary to import green hydrogen. Hydrogen can be transported and stored in various ways, including by putting hydrogen under high pressure (compressed hydrogen) or by cooling it down until it liquefies (liquid hydrogen). An alternative is to use compounds like ammonia or liquid organic hydrogen carriers (LOHC) to reversibly adsorb hydrogen and act as a ‘hydrogen carrier’. Ammonia offers various advantages in terms of transport and storage and is seen as one of the most promising hydrogen carriers. After transport and storage, the hydrogen can be extracted from the ammonia for direct application as hydrogen, or the ammonia can be used, for example, as a zero-carbon fuel or as a replacement for ‘grey’ ammonia in the production of fertiliser. Together with partners, Gasunie is exploring possibilities for building one or more final landing terminals for green ammonia in our core area.

Our investment in heat

WarmtelinQ is a hot water mains that for the most part runs underground. From 2025, the pipeline will take residual heat from industries in the port area of Rotterdam and make this available to around 120,000 homes and businesses in the province of Zuid-Holland. We made the FID to go ahead with the WarmtelinQ project at the end of 2021. Two important pieces of the puzzle for this fell into place in 2021: the signing of an agreement with Eneco, and the grant for WarmtelinQ announced by the national government when they presented the national budget on 21 September 2021. In addition to the investment decision for the heat transmission pipeline from the Port of Rotterdam to The Hague, consultations are underway with the parties involved in an extension of the pipeline from Rijswijk to Leiden. Whether there is sufficient financial and commercial support for this expansion is expected to become clear at the beginning of 2022.

INTERVIEW Green light for WarmtelinQ heat transport pipeline

On 8 November 2021, the Dutch Ministry of Economic Affairs and Climate Policy and Gasunie gave the green light for the construction of WarmtelinQ, a pipeline to transport residual heat from the Port of Rotterdam to the city of The Hague. Community Engagement & Permits Manager Liesbeth Siesling and Floor Hooijman from Business Development at New Energy reflect on the importance of this project for the heat transition. Liesbeth: ‘WarmtelinQ can act as a catalyst for the emergence of new, local initiatives.’

Read the interview

Our investments in green gas

In the Netherlands, the Climate Agreement has set 2 billion cubic metres (bcm) as the target volume of green gas that is to flow through the networks by 2030. Green gas is produced mainly through the fermentation and gasification of biomass. Being the same quality as Groningen gas and entirely carbon-neutral, green gas is a sustainable alternative to natural gas. In 2021, a total of 19 million m3 (185.4 GWh) of green gas was fed into GTS’ networks; for the GUD grid the figure was 113.6 GWh (11.6 million m3).

The Dutch Gas Act sets the boundaries within which GTS can facilitate the market for green gas. For example, GTS can transfer green gas from the grids of regional transmission system operators to the GTS network via green gas boosters, this way helping to increase the scope for injecting green gas into the regional grids. GTS is not allowed to take in, transmit, treat or blend biogas (untreated green gas), even though this could reduce the costs of green gas. For this reason, Gasunie supports the green gas market by making green gas production technologies scalable, such as with the SCW and Torrgas initiatives.

Producing green gas on an industrial scale is a process that presents technical challenges. This makes the development of green gas projects difficult to predict and financially more uncertain. Accordingly, in 2021 decided to remain involved as an infrastructure partner in the above two projects and to offer the green gas market upscaling potential.

Gasunie and SCW Systems are building a demonstration unit for supercritical water gasification at the Energy Innovation Park in Alkmaar. Gasunie and Perpetual Next plan to develop and build the Torrgas Delfzijl project. Together, they intend to build a demonstration installation that, based on Torrgas technology, will eventually be able to produce green gas from syngas in a sustainable manner, with the resulting gas distributed to customers via the existing gas network.

Our investments in CO₂ storage, reuse and transport

Carbon capture and storage (CCS) is one of the very few options that energy-intensive industries – refineries, chemical plants, steel producers, waste processors, cement producers and such – have to avoid large amounts of carbon emissions in the short term and at a relatively low cost. CCS allows these industries to contribute to meeting the climate targets and keeps them in our economy. Carbon capture and utilisation (CCU) can potentially play a key role in decarbonising the greenhouse agriculture sector and will also offer opportunities in other markets in the future. Consequently, carbon capture, utilisation & storage (CCS) is part of the Dutch Climate Agreement and the European Green Deal.

Gasunie is committed to facilitating the development of CCS by developing CO2 transport and storage infrastructure together with partners from across the supply chain. The projects we are working on are Porthos, Carbon Connect Delta, Aramis and CO2nnect. Our Athos CO2 project was terminated in September 2021 because Tata Steel IJmuiden decided to go with DRI technology (‘the hydrogen route’) to accelerate the greening of its steel production. This decision means that too little CO2 will become available in the Amsterdam-IJmond region for a profitable business case for transport and storage under the sea. Tata continues to have the option of storing CO2 through Aramis or CO2nnect.

Porthos: on track

Porthos is on track to store 2.5 megatonnes of CO2 from industry annually in empty gas fields under the North Sea from 2024. In June 2021, the government set aside € 2.1 billion in SDE++ grant money that can be paid out to the project’s customers Air Liquide, Air Products, ExxonMobil and Shell over the next 15 years. The actual funding that will be paid may be significantly lower if the emission allowances (ETS) rate increases in the coming years.

In June 2021, after a European tender process construction company Denys was awarded the contract for the design and construction of the onshore pipeline. The decision on the integration plan and four permit requests (all-in-one permit for physical aspects for the compressor station, all-in-one permit for physical aspects for the P18-A platform, permit for the offshore CO2 transport pipeline, and amendment of the permit for permanent storage of CO2 in reservoir P18-4) are available for inspection.

In November, environmental group Mobilisation for the Environment (MOB) lodged an appeal against the all-in-one permits for physical aspects for the compressor station and the platform and against the integration plan. In December, Air Liquide, Air Products, ExxonMobil and Shell signed final transport and storage contracts with Porthos.

The final decision to proceed with the project is expected in 2022, once the permits for construction and use of the infrastructure and installations have been obtained and the suitability of the contemplated undersea gas field and wells for CO2 storage has definitively been confirmed by the currently ongoing studies into this. Construction of the Porthos system (onshore pipeline, compressor station, offshore pipeline, offshore platform modification) will take approximately two years. In the meantime, the companies will be installing their carbon capture systems. The first ‘deliveries’ of CO2 can then be stored in 2024.

Carbon Connect Delta: CCS in Zeeland and Flanders

In the Delta region of Zeeland and Flanders, Gasunie worked in a consortium with Smart Delta Resources, North Sea Ports and Fluyxs on a study of the feasibility of CCS in the region. Under the name Carbon Connect Delta, the cross-border consortium made plans that could reduce CO2 emissions from industries in Terneuzen, Vlissingen and Ghent by 1 to 6.5 megatonnes a year. An SDE++ grant was requested for the Dutch part in 2021 to build the infrastructure that would be needed to transport CO2, as envisioned, by ship instead of pipeline.

CO2nnect and Aramis: collaboration in the CO2 value chain

We believe that the need for processing captured CO2 goes beyond Rotterdam and Zeeland. Since 2021, CO2nnect, a consortium of Gasunie, Vopak and Gate terminal, has been gauging interest in an independent, open access terminal for the offloading, storage, trans-shipment and delivery of liquid CO2. The terminal would be located in the Maasvlakte area of the Port of Rotterdam. The market survey focuses on industrial companies and clusters without a direct connection to a CO2 pipeline. They can transport CO2 to the terminal by coaster, inland waterway vessel and perhaps also by train or truck. In its first phase CO2nnect could process 7 megatonnes of CO2.

CO2nnect is working on its market study together with Aramis, a consortium of Gasunie, TotalEnergies, Shell Nederland and Energie Beheer Nederland that started in 2021. Aramis aims to build a pipeline to transport CO2 from a CO2 collection point and compressor station in the Port of Rotterdam area to the offshore platforms where the CO2 would be injected into empty gas fields using existing wells. These gas fields are located about three to four kilometres under the North Sea bed. The Aramis infrastructure must also be freely accessible so that industrial customers and operators from other fields can gradually be added to the system. Aramis aims to make a final investment decision in 2023 with an operational start in 2026. The CO2 transport infrastructure could transfer 5 megatonnes of CO2 to the storage fields every year.

The project teams behind CO2nnect and Aramis are looking at mutual synergy and collaboration with Porthos. The plan is to connect the CO2nnect terminal to the Aramis pipeline.

Possible undersea storage of imported CO₂?

The CCS projects in which Gasunie participates mainly concern the storage of CO2 produced in the Netherlands. From a legal perspective, CO2 from abroad is currently not allowed to be transported and stored on Dutch territory. Not only is there sufficient capacity under the seabed off the Dutch North Sea coast to meet the Dutch demand for CO2 storage,

there is enough capacity to meet the storage demands of neighbouring countries too. The storage of this foreign CO2 is still uncertain and depends on political policy and choices. Gasunie follows the line of the Dutch government and can cooperate in the transport and storage of imported CO2 if there is a legal basis and support for this.

Aramis has been placed on the EU list of Important Projects of European Common Interest (for key cross-border infrastructure projects) and as such has IPCEI status, which is both a qualification for projects to be seen as sustainable and useful in a European context and a condition for eligibility for EU funding for sustainability initiatives.

What we are doing to reduce the environmental impact of our gas transmission system

The transmission of natural gas requires energy, energy we use to keep the gas grid at pressure, to blend natural gas with nitrogen, and to compensate for frictional losses during transmission. Gasunie uses natural gas and electricity for this. Burning this natural gas and generating this electricity produces CO2 and NOx emissions.

Furthermore, natural gas is emitted to the air during management and maintenance work on our infrastructure. This happens:

  • when starting and stopping compressors;
  • when operating equipment using natural gas pressure (pneumatic components);
  • in the case of slow leaks (at couplings, etc.);
  • during work on the transmission network.

Natural gas consists primarily of methane. Just like carbon dioxide, methane is a greenhouse gas*. The total methane emissions along the entire natural gas supply chain cannot yet be determined with certainty. We expect that better measurement methods, such as drone-based and space-based (satellite) laser metrology, will become available in the short term to pinpoint the sources of leaks from across the energy sector.

* We calculate the contribution to the greenhouse gas effect in carbon dioxide equivalent (CO2e). For the purposes of our calculation, we assume that in the short term 1 kilogramme of methane contributes 25 times as much to climate change as 1 kilogramme of carbon dioxide.

Our emissions

We report carbon emissions in accordance with the rules of the Greenhouse Gas Protocol. These emissions are categorised in three groups (‘Scopes’). The footprint is expressed in CO2e. This means that emissions resulting from energy usage and natural gas emissions are converted into an equivalent volume of CO2, which then serves as a measure of these emissions’ global-warming potential.
 

CO2e emissions according to the GHG Protocol (in metric tonnes of CO2-equivalents)

Our emission reduction efforts

Our measures against methane emissions

Reducing our carbon footprint is hugely important to us. We are reducing our methane emissions by using:

  1. Emission-free regulating equipment
  2. LDAR programme
  3. Nitrogen displacement
  4. Mobile recompression
  5. Mobile flaring

Our measures regarding other CO₂ emissions

Our carbon footprint reduction ambitions

New, company-wide targets

In 2021, for the first time we set a corporate-wide target for both our CO2 and methane emissions. This makes it easier for us to compare the emission reduction results of our various business units, and third parties can better compare our total results with that of other network operators.

  • 2030: our methane emissions should be about 50% lower than in 2020. To achieve this, the methane emissions must fall below 70 kilotonnes of CO2e.
  • 2030: we want to reduce our total CO2 emissions (i.e. including methane emissions) relating to our natural gas transmission (Scope 1+2) by 30% by 2030 compared to 2020, assuming constant transmission volumes. The formula for this is
    CO2e (kton) = 70 (kton CO2e) + (0.137 × transport volume)

Internal carbon pricing

To be able to make the right investment decisions in the design, construction, use and replacement of installations, Gasunie uses internal carbon pricing. In line with market trends, this price has risen sharply:

  • 2020: € 25 per metric tonne CO2
  • 2021: € 50 per metric tonne CO2
  • 2022: € 100 per metric tonne CO2

Methane Guiding Principles

In 2019, we became a signatory to the Methane Guiding Principles, which are backed by a voluntary, international coalition of companies operating in the natural gas supply chain that has resolved to bring down methane emissions significantly. In 2021 we agreed within this coalition to replace gas-emitting pressure regulators with non-emitting regulators at several installations. This results in a saving of approximately 25 metric tonnes of methane per year at these installations. In 2021, Gasunie actively participated in study groups in the Oil and Gas Methane Partnership (OGMP) to draw up reporting models, emission factors and calculation methods for top-down measurements. Under its OGMP membership, Gasunie has drawn up an action plan for how we can achieve, within the set period, the OGMP Gold Standard score for assets over which Gasunie has operational control and for our participations.

In 2021, the European Commission launched a strategy to further bring down methane emissions in the energy industry. The main elements of the European Commission’s paper are focused on transparent reporting, running LDAR (leak detection and repair) programmes and reducing natural gas venting and flaring in the energy industry. In December 2021, the European Commission published the draft legislative proposal for this. OGMP 2.0 is intended as a framework for the European Commission for a legislative proposal on the measurement, reporting and verification of methane emissions in the energy industry.

Our methane emissions

Our methane emissions over the past five years were as follows (in tonnes of methane):

Methane emissions Netherlands  Germany 
2021  4071 1085
2020  4000 1510
2019  4176  405 
2018  4712  470 
2017  4619  354 

Methane emissions in perspective

Reducing methane emissions has long been a strategic priority for Gasunie. Compared to 1990, the company has reduced its methane emissions by almost 50% (from 272,000 tonnes CO2e in 1990 to 138,000 tonnes CO2e in 2020). Looking at recent performance, we see a 21% reduction in the period 2016-2020. Our target of a 50% cut in methane emissions by 2050 compared to 2020 levels is more ambitious than that of the Global Methane Pledge (of the United States, European Union and partners), which aims to reduce methane emissions by 30% by 2050 compared to 2020 levels.

We expect methane emissions to decrease in the coming years. In 2021, however, on the whole we saw them go up. This increase for the Netherlands relates to increased emissions as a result of turbine starts and stops and a leaking safety valve at one of our compressor stations, among other causes. For Germany, there has been increased insight from the year 2020 thanks to the OGMP reporting model; for this reason the methane emission figure for Germany in 2020 has been adjusted retrospectively in this 2021 annual report. The reduction in Germany in 2021 compared to 2020 is the result of fewer operating hours for the compressors as well as various measurements and insights gained in 2021.

As in 2020, in 2021 we determined that our LDAR programme was leading to a reduction in emissions in the Netherlands thanks to the monitoring for leaks and repairing any leaks detected. Modifications to the control system of a number of Gasunie gas turbines have reduced the level of unburned methane emissions from these turbines.  The methane emissions caused by Gasunie represent approximately 0.6% of the total methane emissions in the Netherlands.

Our other environmental impact

Our NOₓ emissions

Our NOx emissions over the past five years were as follows (in tonnes of NOx):

  Netherlands Germany 
2021  83 69
2020  71  79 
2019  59  42 
2018  95  29 
2017  83  29 

Our overall NOx emissions in 2021 compared to 2020 have remained roughly the same, though an upward trend starting from 2019 can be seen. This is the result of the compressor stations in the Netherlands being in operation more often in 2021 compared to 2020 and 2019.

Environmental irregularities

We keep records of environmental irregularities in order to learn from them and, where possible, take effective action to limit environmental damage in the future. The number of environmental irregularities reported for Gasunie in the Netherlands and Germany was:

Environmental irregularities 2021 2020 2019
Non-compliance with environmental laws and regulations 3 0 1
Irregularity with respect to the environmental management system 1 0 0
Environmental incidents 38 27 48
Third-party nuisance complaints 125 108 103
       
Total 167 135 152

The large majority of the environmental irregularities are reports from third parties about smelling gas or minor leaks. There were more complaints from third parties in 2021 compared to 2020 and 2019. The number of reports from third parties in which, on inspection by Gasunie, no irregularity was found remained approximately the same in 2021 compared to 2020 (45 versus 46 respectively). More noise-related complaints were received in 2021.

The incidents of non-compliance with environmental laws and regulations concerned the following:

  • The flue gas cleaning system of two gas turbines at Ravenstein failed for 27 and 13 hours respectively (two non-compliance incidents).
  • One gas receiving station did not comply with prevailing noise regulations.

As in 2020, in 2021 Gasunie received no significant environmental fines.

Safe grids, safe environment

Uncontrolled events

Uncontrolled events are incidents involving gas leaks ((natural) gas, hydrogen, nitrogen, air) of over 14,000m3 from a Gasunie-operated pressure holder with a rated pressure of 8 bar or higher. No uncontrolled events occurred in 2021 (2020: 0). Starting in 2022, Gasunie will tighten the requirement for the maximum number of uncontrolled events, from 3 annually to no more than 2 per year.

Pipeline inspections

To safeguard the integrity of the pipeline systems, GTS and GUD inspect part of their pipeline system annually. In 2021, GTS carried out internal inspections (‘pig runs’) of 209 kilometres of pipeline. GTS also inspected four kilometres of pipeline above ground using External Corrosion Direct Assessments (ECDA).

European benchmark for pipeline incidents

All European gas TSOs register their pipeline incidents in the same way, making it possible to compare their performance with their peers. Registration occurs via the European Gas Pipeline Incident Data Group (EGIG), which registers both pipeline lengths and pipeline incidents with gas leaks.

EGIG data is used to determine the ‘failure frequency’. This is the frequency (per km per year) of pipeline incidents with gas leaks due to, for instance, excavation activities, corrosion, construction defects and material defects.

With regard to pipeline incidents with gas leaks, we score slightly better than the European average. In the past few years, the sector’s performance has steadily improved. In 2021, the score for Gasunie was approximately 0.04 incidents per 1,000km per year (2020: 0.07); this was the lowest score for Gasunie since 2006. The EGIG incident rate for Gasunie in 2020 was 0.11.

  EGIG Gasunie
2007 0.14 0.14
2008 0.16 0.17
2009 0.16 0.12
2010 0.16 0.08
2011 0.17 0.11
2012 0.17 0.13
2013 0.16 0.1
2014 0.13 0.11
2015 0.14 0.12
2016 0.14 0.12
2017 0.14 0.11
2018 0.13 0.11
2019 0.13 0.1
2020 0.11 0.07000000000000001
2021   0.04

Improved sustainable performance: ESG ratings

  2021 2020 2019
Sustainalytics 19.3 24.4 29
ISS-ESG B C+ -

In addition to credit ratings, Gasunie also has an ESG rating, a figure that indicates the extent to which a undertaking operates sustainably and responsibly.

Sustainalytics

Our ESG rating at Sustainalytics was 19.3 in 2021, an improvement on 2020, when it was 24.4 (29.0 in 2019). The lower the score, the better Gasunie manages its ESG risks. Our score this year puts us in third place in a corporate social responsibility ranking of 99 gas companies.
 

Gasunie’s ESG risk profile according to Sustainalytics

ISS-ESG

Rating agency ISS-ESG gave us a B rating in 2021. This puts us in the international top 20% of 52 operators of gas and electricity networks. We are also in the top 20% in terms of transparency. ISS-ESG makes its assessment based on approximately 100 criteria, specifically aimed at network operators. On a scale that ranges from D- (very low) to A+ (very high), ISS-ESG awarded Gasunie a C+ in 2020.

In the field of environmentally safe and employee-safe management of our infrastructure, in particular, we score considerably higher than the industry average, according to ISS-ESG. We are also better than average in ‘facilitating the energy transition and using energy efficiently’ and ‘ethical business practices, and relationship with public bodies’. And, according to ISS-ESG, thanks to our investment strategy for green gas, hydrogen, heat and CCS, we are in a better position than the average network operator to contribute to global sustainability goals.

Volgend hoofdstuk: 06 Our internal economic value creation